We are one of FOE's local groups, organised like other groups in Wales through FOE Cymru, whose office is in Cardiff - Castle Arcade Balcony, tel 029 20229577. Contact us, Barry&Vale FoE via greenkeith 'at' virginmedia.com, tel. 07716 895973

Monday 17 October 2011

Scrutiny exposure of Fracking in the Vale

Vale E&E Scrutiny Committee on FRACKING,
  in Council Chamber, Barry 17 Oct. 2011

A range of protesters and independents were permitted to put a 10-minute case to the Committee, with the applicants (a 'family' business, Coastal Oil and Gas) taking twice that long. Cllr Chris Williams in the Chair told everyone not to relate it to the planning application, but then the chief Officer outlined his planning report on the Llandow application. He reported the reply from the First Minister to the Council Leader as arriving too late, giving no guidance and “in essence” saying the application was for local determination. Yet that letter arrived on the day of the evening planning committee (29 Sept.) but was held back, presumably as it said of unconventional gas extraction that
  •  “there are additional environmental considerations” and
  •  “a precautionary approach should be taken”.
As well as Louis Evans of ValeSaysNo, an ex-industrial chemist Chris Smith and a US investigative journalist Dennis Campbell, were most impressive. Prof. Joe Cartwright of Cardiff Uni tried to argue the fracking process had been used for decades, but was slapped down by others saying it's near horizontal drilling along the strata and injection of chemicals at high pressure with extraction of flow water that is new. Friends of the Earth speaker, Max Wallis, stressed that the leaks of methane in fracking make it as bad as coal – so a switch to fracking-gas fuel can't help meet the UK's carbon targets.

Cllr Rob Curtis, who'd called for the special meeting, proposed a paper motion calling for a suspension of fracking permits until public concerns had been assuaged – and none of the Committee dared vote against. One said forcefully that there's no regulatory regime in place – despite government talk that the public should rely on the Environment Agency as regulator – as fracking for gas is fundamentally different from coal mining and oil extraction. Another said “precaution” requires us to wait a few years pending sufficient evidence.

No comments:

Post a Comment